User:ZeFredz/AmendmentsTool - Revision history

ZeFredz: /* State of the art */

2015-03-03T20:48:34Z

State of the art

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:48, 3 March 2015
Line 13:		Line 13:
	* GetOpinionated : http://opinion.pirateparty.be (libre & open source GPL)		* GetOpinionated : http://opinion.pirateparty.be (libre & open source GPL)
	* AT4AM : http://www.at4am.org tool developped for EU (libre & open source EUPL)		* AT4AM : http://www.at4am.org tool developped for EU (libre & open source EUPL)
			* DemocracyOS : http://democracyos.org/
	* Wirite : http://main.wirite.org/ (proprietary, source not available at this time)		* Wirite : http://main.wirite.org/ (proprietary, source not available at this time)
	* Co-ment : http://www.co-ment.org/ Descendant of the software used to write GPL V3.		* Co-ment : http://www.co-ment.org/ Descendant of the software used to write GPL V3.
Line 27:		Line 28:

	* iMio.be (ex-communesplone) : http://www.imio.be/		* iMio.be (ex-communesplone) : http://www.imio.be/
			* Swarmops : https://github.com/Swarmops/Swarmops

	==Analysis of existing tools==		==Analysis of existing tools==

ZeFredz: /* Co-ment - Good for */

2014-07-30T09:48:57Z

Co-ment - Good for

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:48, 30 July 2014
Line 89:		Line 89:
	* text annotation by multiple users.		* text annotation by multiple users.
	* discussion		* discussion
	* ?		* navigation (TOC, versions, display of comments, discussion thread)

	==== Co-ment - Lacks of====		==== Co-ment - Lacks of====

ZeFredz: /* Co-ment - Lacks of */

2014-07-30T09:48:27Z

Co-ment - Lacks of

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:48, 30 July 2014
Line 92:		Line 92:

	==== Co-ment - Lacks of====		==== Co-ment - Lacks of====
	* ?		* translation support (as far as I know)

	==Requirements for an Proposals/Amendments management tool==		==Requirements for an Proposals/Amendments management tool==

	working on it...		working on it...

Manu: add co-ment in the list

2014-07-30T09:35:32Z

add co-ment in the list

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:35, 30 July 2014
Line 14:		Line 14:
	* AT4AM : http://www.at4am.org tool developped for EU (libre & open source EUPL)		* AT4AM : http://www.at4am.org tool developped for EU (libre & open source EUPL)
	* Wirite : http://main.wirite.org/ (proprietary, source not available at this time)		* Wirite : http://main.wirite.org/ (proprietary, source not available at this time)
			* Co-ment : http://www.co-ment.org/ Descendant of the software used to write GPL V3.
	* Git		* Git
	** German Laws on GitHub : https://github.com/bundestag/gesetze		** German Laws on GitHub : https://github.com/bundestag/gesetze
Line 83:		Line 84:
	* A way to add references (links, documents...) on proposals		* A way to add references (links, documents...) on proposals
	* Collaborative proposals/amendments writing		* Collaborative proposals/amendments writing

			=== Co-ment===
			==== Co-ment - Good for ====
			* text annotation by multiple users.
			* discussion
			* ?

			==== Co-ment - Lacks of====
			* ?

	==Requirements for an Proposals/Amendments management tool==		==Requirements for an Proposals/Amendments management tool==

	working on it...		working on it...

ZeFredz: add goals and motivation

2014-07-28T08:41:43Z

add goals and motivation

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:41, 28 July 2014
Line 1:		Line 1:
	==~~Liste d~~'~~outils existants~~==		==Coals and motivation==

			Set up a tool to manage proposals and amendments for parliamentary/legislative/judiciary texts. This tool or set of tools will have to provide an intuitive user-friendly interface and handle history and translations. The goal here is to list the existing solutions, to analyse them and to create a list of requirements for such a platform.

			'''Motivation''' : We are currently using several tools to manage our GA preparation process but none of theme is currently meeting the requirements to create a complete eDemocracy online platform that anybody can use. This platform will have to work in a multi-language environment which will be a real challenge to solve !

			http://movecommons.org/mc/0.1/images/np-rp-rc.to-gr-88x31-0.1.png
			[http://movecommons.org/en/np-rp-rc.to-gr/0.1/ Move Commons Non-Profit, Reproducible, Reinforcing the Town/community/society Commons, Grassroots]

			==State of the art==

	* MediaWiki (libre & open source GPL) - example : [[Events/EGA:2014-08/Amendments]]		* MediaWiki (libre & open source GPL) - example : [[Events/EGA:2014-08/Amendments]]
Line 9:		Line 18:
	* Pads (etherpad-lite)		* Pads (etherpad-lite)

	===Standards ~~et formats de fichier~~===		===Standards & data structures===

	* http://www.akomantoso.org/ : "Akoma Ntoso (“linked hearts” in Akan language of West Africa) defines a “machine readable” set of simple technology-neutral electronic representations (in XML format) of parliamentary, legislative and judiciary documents."		* http://www.akomantoso.org/ : "Akoma Ntoso (“linked hearts” in Akan language of West Africa) defines a “machine readable” set of simple technology-neutral electronic representations (in XML format) of parliamentary, legislative and judiciary documents."

ZeFredz: /* Standards et formats de fichier */

2014-07-28T07:08:45Z

Standards et formats de fichier

← Older revision		Revision as of 09:08, 28 July 2014
Line 12:		Line 12:

	* http://www.akomantoso.org/ : "Akoma Ntoso (“linked hearts” in Akan language of West Africa) defines a “machine readable” set of simple technology-neutral electronic representations (in XML format) of parliamentary, legislative and judiciary documents."		* http://www.akomantoso.org/ : "Akoma Ntoso (“linked hearts” in Akan language of West Africa) defines a “machine readable” set of simple technology-neutral electronic representations (in XML format) of parliamentary, legislative and judiciary documents."
			* Markdown + structure of documents (German laws on GitHub)

	===Other tools to look at===		===Other tools to look at===

ZeFredz: /* GetOp - Lacks of */

2014-07-28T06:59:09Z

GetOp - Lacks of

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:59, 28 July 2014
Line 71:		Line 71:
	* A way to create new proposals from amendments		* A way to create new proposals from amendments
	* Versionning and history on proposals		* Versionning and history on proposals
	* Translation system on proposals/amendments~~/comments~~		* Translation system on proposals/amendments
	* A way to add references (links, documents...) on proposals		* A way to add references (links, documents...) on proposals
			* Collaborative proposals/amendments writing

	==Requirements for an Proposals/Amendments management tool==		==Requirements for an Proposals/Amendments management tool==

	working on it...		working on it...

ZeFredz: /* Liste d'outils existants */

2014-07-28T06:58:38Z

Liste d'outils existants

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:58, 28 July 2014
Line 13:		Line 13:
	* http://www.akomantoso.org/ : "Akoma Ntoso (“linked hearts” in Akan language of West Africa) defines a “machine readable” set of simple technology-neutral electronic representations (in XML format) of parliamentary, legislative and judiciary documents."		* http://www.akomantoso.org/ : "Akoma Ntoso (“linked hearts” in Akan language of West Africa) defines a “machine readable” set of simple technology-neutral electronic representations (in XML format) of parliamentary, legislative and judiciary documents."


			===Other tools to look at===

			* iMio.be (ex-communesplone) : http://www.imio.be/

	==Analysis of existing tools==		==Analysis of existing tools==

ZeFredz: /* Analysis of existing tools */ add getop

2014-07-28T06:55:30Z

Analysis of existing tools: add getop

@@ Line 26: / Line 26: @@
 The Wiki has been used for the Amendments for the August 2014 GA
 ====MediaWiki - Good for====
@@ Line 35: / Line 37: @@
 ====MediaWiki - Lacks of====
 * Clarity when mixing proposals and amendments on a page
@@ Line 43: / Line 43: @@
 * Easier way to debate/discuss on amendments and proposals
 * Parliamentary/Legislative/Judiciary specific structures of documents
 * User-friendliness if your are not a fan of the Wiki tool
 * Seing amendments/questions/discussions in the page flow can be tricky

ZeFredz: /* Lacks of */

2014-07-28T06:48:49Z

Lacks of

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:48, 28 July 2014
Line 21:		Line 21:
	====ToolName - Good for====		====ToolName - Good for====

	====Lacks of====		====ToolName - Lacks of====

	===MediaWiki===		===MediaWiki===