Events/EGA:2014-08/Results - Revision history

Franky: Bot: Fixing redirects

2017-09-25T22:44:36Z

Bot: Fixing redirects

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:44, 26 September 2017
Line 3:		Line 3:
	We have been voting on [http://wiki.pirateparty.be/images/6/6d/Pp_EGA_aug_2014.pdf the following document].		We have been voting on [http://wiki.pirateparty.be/images/6/6d/Pp_EGA_aug_2014.pdf the following document].

	The proposals can be found [[~~Events/~~EGA:2014~~-08/Proposals~~\|here]].		The proposals can be found [[file:Pp EGA aug 2014.pdf\|here]].

	Total voters : 32		Total voters : 32

Franky: convert external links into internal links

2017-02-11T16:50:17Z

convert external links into internal links

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:50, 11 February 2017
Line 3:		Line 3:
	We have been voting on [http://wiki.pirateparty.be/images/6/6d/Pp_EGA_aug_2014.pdf the following document].		We have been voting on [http://wiki.pirateparty.be/images/6/6d/Pp_EGA_aug_2014.pdf the following document].

	The proposals can be found [~~http://wiki.pirateparty.be/index.php/~~Events/EGA:2014-08/Proposals here].		The proposals can be found [[Events/EGA:2014-08/Proposals\|here]].

	Total voters : 32		Total voters : 32

Alexis: /* Motie 3: Structuur - Motion 3: Structure */

2014-08-10T18:32:14Z

Motie 3: Structuur - Motion 3: Structure

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:32, 10 August 2014
Line 141:		Line 141:
	==== Vote 21: (postponed) ====		==== Vote 21: (postponed) ====

	13 green / 14 red		* 13 green / 14 red : postponed.

	a new proposal will be made based on the discussions prior to voting		A new proposal will be made based on the discussions prior to voting. The 3.2 and 3.3 don't make sense without 3.1. It's decided to skip 3.2 and 3.3.

	~~So we will~~ skip 3.2 and 3.3

	=== 3.2 Secretariaat - secrétariat ===		=== 3.2 Secretariaat - secrétariat ===
Line 160:		Line 158:
	==== Vote 30: (postponed) ====		==== Vote 30: (postponed) ====
	==== Vote 31: (postponed) ====		==== Vote 31: (postponed) ====

	=== 3.4 Squads - Squads ===		=== 3.4 Squads - Squads ===
	Remark : the squads concerned by vote 32-35 are defined afterwards		Remark 1: the squads concerned by vote 32-35 are defined afterwards.

			Remark 2: a vote based on the general principle of '''delegating some responsibilities of the Coreteam to Squads and allowing the Coreteam to take back those responsibilities''' is made (decision at the simple majority) -> accepted.

			Remark 3 : the Squads should be reworded "Operational Squads" in this context.

	Vote ~~on the general principle to delegate certain responsibilities of the coreteam to squads and to allow the coreteam to take back those~~		==== Vote 32: A & B accepted ====
			* A: accepted.
			* B: accepted.

	~~responsibilities (decision at the simple majority) -> accepted~~		Remark: in this vote, A and B don't exclude each other.

	~~Squads should be reworded "operational squads" in this context~~		==== Vote 33: A & B accepted ====
			* A:accepted.
			* B: accepted.

	~~==== Vote 32: B & C ====~~
	~~A: accepted~~
	~~B: accepted~~
	~~==== Vote 33: A & B====~~
	~~A:accepted~~
	~~B: accepted~~
	==== Vote 34: accepted ====		==== Vote 34: accepted ====

	=== 3.5 Coaching-squad - L'escouade Coaching ===		=== 3.5 Coaching-squad - L'escouade Coaching ===
	==== Vote 35: accepted ====		==== Vote 35: accepted ====

	=== 3.6 Coordinatie-squad - L'escouade de coordination ===		=== 3.6 Coordinatie-squad - L'escouade de coordination ===
	==== Vote 36: accepted ====		==== Vote 36: accepted ====

	==== Vote 37: rejected ====		==== Vote 37: rejected ====
	7 green / more red		* 7 green / more red

	==== Vote 38: accepted ====		==== Vote 38: accepted ====

	=== 3.7 Coreteam-squad - L'escouade Coreteam ===		=== 3.7 Coreteam-squad - L'escouade Coreteam ===
	==== Vote 39: not voted ====		==== Vote 39: not voted ====
	This is inconsistent with previous decisions -> ~~will not~~ vote 39		This is inconsistent with previous decisions -> no vote on 39.

	==== Vote 40: accepted ====		==== Vote 40: accepted ====

	=== 3.8 Financien-squad - L'escouade Finance ===		=== 3.8 Financien-squad - L'escouade Finance ===

	==== Vote 41 : B accepted with a remark ====		==== Vote 41 : accepted with a remark ====
	~~Who approves~~ the budget ?		Remark 1 : issue concerning the translation in French. Reworded in "Mettre en oeuvre le budget approuvé par l'Assemblée Générale." A vote is made to approve this.
	A ~~green Coreteam : rejected~~

	B red GA : accepted		Who approves the budget ? The Coreteam (A) or the GA (B) ?
			* A : ? green : rejected.
			* B : majority of red : accepted.

	~~Remarks~~ : what will happen if the GA ~~don't~~ approve the budget ? -> need a proposal ~~on that at~~ next GA		Remark 2 : what will happen if the GA does not approve the budget ? We need a proposal concerning this for the next GA.

	==== Vote 42: accepted ====		==== Vote 42: accepted ====

	=== 3.9 Algemene Vergadering-squad - L'escouade AG ===		=== 3.9 Algemene Vergadering-squad - L'escouade AG ===
	==== Vote 43: accepted ====		==== Vote 43: accepted ====

	=== 3.10 IT-squad - L'escouade IT ===		=== 3.10 IT-squad - L'escouade IT ===
	==== Vote 44: accepted ====		==== Vote 44: accepted ====
	~~=== 3.11 Pers-squad - L'escouade Presse ===~~

	NB: not about opinion letters (in personal name), only press releases of the party		=== 3.11 Pres-squad - L'escouade Presse ===
			Remark 1: this is not about opinion letters (written in a personal name), but only press releases in the name of the party.
	~~Question~~: what about local press?		Remark 2: what about local press?

	==== Vote 45: accepted ====		==== Vote 45: accepted ====
	=== 3.12 Secretariaat-squad - L'escouade Secrétariat ===		=== 3.12 Secretariaat-squad - L'escouade Secrétariat ===
			Remark : shouldn't we make it possible for the Coreteam to access the list of members by itself?

	~~Question: shouldn't we make it possible for the coreteam to access the list of members by itself?~~
	==== Vote 46: accepted ====		==== Vote 46: accepted ====

Line 219:		Line 228:

	=== 3.14 Naam - Nom ===		=== 3.14 Naam - Nom ===
	~~It's about finding a name for the "operational squads"~~
	==== Vote 48: Operational Squad ====		==== Vote 48: Operational Squad ====
			It's about finding a name for the "operational squads". Four names are voted : Operational Squads vs. "who cares" vs. "squads" vs. "organs".
	Operational Squads (vs. "who cares" vs. "squads" vs. "organs")

	=== 3.15 Procedures - Procédures ===		=== 3.15 Procedures - Procédures ===
	==== Vote 49: Simple Majority ====		==== Vote 49: Simple Majority ====
	~~Issue~~ with wording: motie van wantrouwen and motion de défiance instead of vertrouwen/confiance. It's about getting someone out.		Remark : there is an issue with wording: "motie van wantrouwen" and "motion de défiance" instead of vertrouwen/confiance. It's about getting someone out.
			>>> Voted for simple majority (not special majority).
	Voted for simple majority (not special majority)

	==== Vote ~~49'~~ : accepted ====		==== Vote 49bis : accepted ====
	also ~~applies~~ to the ~~coreteam -> accepted~~		Is the 49 also applied to the Coreteam ? Accepted.

	==== Vote 50: accepted ====		==== Vote 50: accepted ====

Alexis: /* Vote 20: A & B accepted */

2014-08-10T18:02:43Z

Vote 20: A & B accepted

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:02, 10 August 2014
Line 131:		Line 131:

	Remark 1: if there is no coordination squad, the Coreteam takes its role.		Remark 1: if there is no coordination squad, the Coreteam takes its role.

	Remark 2: concerning B, it's decided to delete the first part, a copy-paste of A : "Elke piraat die een project start moet de coördinatie-squad contacteren met de volgende informatie: een beschrijving van het project en een contactpersoon. De coördinatie-squad registreert het project formeel na verificatie dat het de statuten en de waarden van de partij respecteert." / "Chaque pirate lançant un projet doit contacter l'escouade de coordination avec les informations suivantes : une description du projet et une personne de contact. L'escouade de coordination enregistre dans les faits le projet après avoir vérifié qu'il respecte les statuts et les valeurs du parti."		Remark 2: concerning B, it's decided to delete the first part, a copy-paste of A : "Elke piraat die een project start moet de coördinatie-squad contacteren met de volgende informatie: een beschrijving van het project en een contactpersoon. De coördinatie-squad registreert het project formeel na verificatie dat het de statuten en de waarden van de partij respecteert." / "Chaque pirate lançant un projet doit contacter l'escouade de coordination avec les informations suivantes : une description du projet et une personne de contact. L'escouade de coordination enregistre dans les faits le projet après avoir vérifié qu'il respecte les statuts et les valeurs du parti."

Alexis: /* Vote 20: A & B */

2014-08-10T18:02:26Z

Vote 20: A & B

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:02, 10 August 2014
Line 128:		Line 128:
	* B : majority of red: accepted.		* B : majority of red: accepted.

	==== Vote 20: A & B====		==== Vote 20: A & B accepted ====

	Remark: if there is no coordination ~~team~~, it's the ~~coreteam that takes this role~~		Remark 1: if there is no coordination squad, the Coreteam takes its role.
			Remark 2: concerning B, it's decided to delete the first part, a copy-paste of A : "Elke piraat die een project start moet de coördinatie-squad contacteren met de volgende informatie: een beschrijving van het project en een contactpersoon. De coördinatie-squad registreert het project formeel na verificatie dat het de statuten en de waarden van de partij respecteert." / "Chaque pirate lançant un projet doit contacter l'escouade de coordination avec les informations suivantes : une description du projet et une personne de contact. L'escouade de coordination enregistre dans les faits le projet après avoir vérifié qu'il respecte les statuts et les valeurs du parti."

	A : accepted		* A : accepted.
	B: 15 green / 10 red -> accepted		* B : 15 green / 10 red -> accepted.

	== Motie 3: Structuur - Motion 3: Structure ==		== Motie 3: Structuur - Motion 3: Structure ==

Alexis: /* Vote 19: A */

2014-08-10T17:55:52Z

Vote 19: A

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:55, 10 August 2014
Line 124:		Line 124:
	Remark : what's a project ? we will have to define this		Remark : what's a project ? we will have to define this

	==== Vote 19: A ====		==== Vote 19: B accepted ====
	A : rejected		* A : rejected.
			* B : majority of red: accepted.
	B : accepted

	==== Vote 20: A & B====		==== Vote 20: A & B====

Alexis: /* Vote 18: accepted */

2014-08-10T17:53:05Z

Vote 18: accepted

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:53, 10 August 2014
Line 117:		Line 117:
	==== Vote 18: accepted ====		==== Vote 18: accepted ====

	Idea from ~~the~~ the discussion :		==== Idea from the discussion ====

	~~motivation of the~~ decision ~~from the conflict resolution group/mediation team~~		The Conflict Resolution Group or Mediation Team will have to motivate his decision.

	=== 2.3 Projecten - Projets ===		=== 2.3 Projecten - Projets ===

Alexis: /* Vote 17: B accepted */

2014-08-10T17:50:24Z

Vote 17: B accepted

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:50, 10 August 2014
Line 112:		Line 112:
	==== Vote 16: accepted ====		==== Vote 16: accepted ====
	==== Vote 17: B accepted ====		==== Vote 17: B accepted ====
	* A green :		* A : ? green.
	* B : majority of red : accepted		* B : majority of red : accepted.

	==== Vote 18: accepted ====		==== Vote 18: accepted ====

Alexis: /* Vote 17: B */

2014-08-10T17:49:46Z

Vote 17: B

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:49, 10 August 2014
Line 111:		Line 111:
	==== Vote 15: accepted ====		==== Vote 15: accepted ====
	==== Vote 16: accepted ====		==== Vote 16: accepted ====
	==== Vote 17: B ====		==== Vote 17: B accepted ====
	A green :		* A green :
			* B : majority of red : accepted
	B red : accepted

	==== Vote 18: accepted ====		==== Vote 18: accepted ====

Alexis: /* Vote 13: accepted */

2014-08-10T17:46:27Z

Vote 13: accepted

← Older revision		Revision as of 19:46, 10 August 2014
Line 89:		Line 89:
	==== Vote 13: accepted ====		==== Vote 13: accepted ====

	Remark: ~~remove~~ "coreteam election" because it's every 6 months		Remark: "coreteam election" is removed because it happens every 6 months and this doesn't make sense with the proposal.

	==== Vote 14: (Postponed) ====		==== Vote 14: (Postponed) ====