Events/EGA:2014-01/voting-day1 - Revision history

Vincent.L at 11:31, 25 January 2014

2014-01-25T11:31:15Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:31, 25 January 2014
Line 1:		Line 1:
	~~=Results of EGA2014-01 Voting - day 1=~~

	=='''Program'''==		=='''Program'''==

Vincent.L: /* Statutes */

2014-01-25T11:27:09Z

Statutes

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:27, 25 January 2014
Line 86:		Line 86:
	Suggestion: Let's try to discuss more and answer to objections instead of voting directly		Suggestion: Let's try to discuss more and answer to objections instead of voting directly

			12: Whole block Rejected, because no consensus (no vote)

	12A:		12A:
	Y:		Y:
Line 97:		Line 99:
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	~~Whole block Rejected, because no consensus (no vote)~~

	13:		13: Rejected
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	Remark: risk that a new specific rule will be made each time someone is to be kicked out?		Remark: risk that a new specific rule will be made each time someone is to be kicked out?
	~~Rejected~~

	14:		14: Accepted
	Y:16+6=22		Y:16+6=22
	N:6+5=11		N:6+5=11
	~~Accepted~~

Vincent.L: Protected "Events/EGA:2014-01/voting-day1": Official results, can't be changed ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

2014-01-25T11:25:58Z

Protected "Events/EGA:2014-01/voting-day1": Official results, can't be changed ([Edit=Allow only administrators] (indefinite) [Move=Allow only administrators] (indefinite))

← Older revision	Revision as of 13:25, 25 January 2014
(No difference)

Vincent.L: /* Program */

2014-01-25T11:24:59Z

Program

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:24, 25 January 2014
Line 3:		Line 3:
	=='''Program'''==		=='''Program'''==

	1:		1: postponed
	Y: 14 + 3 =17		Y: 14 + 3 =17
	N: 9 +9= 18		N: 9 +9= 18
	~~postponed~~
	Remark:		Remark:
	-Think about implication towards who owns this debt (to debate in arglab?)		-Think about implication towards who owns this debt (to debate in arglab?)
	-This is the same as bankrupt ?		-This is the same as bankrupt ?

	2:		2: accepted
	Y: 16 + 8= 24		Y: 16 + 8= 24
	N:10 + 4= 14		N:10 + 4= 14
	~~accepted~~

	3:		3: Accepted
	Y:11+ 10=21		Y:11+ 10=21
	N:12+3 = 15		N:12+3 = 15
	Remark: "The most important" could be excessive		Remark: "The most important" could be excessive
	~~Accepted~~

	4:		4: Rejected (no need to count)
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	Remark: there is more to do about animal rights than banning hunt		Remark: there is more to do about animal rights than banning hunt
	Question: is it also about fishing?		Question: is it also about fishing?
	No, just hunting		No, just hunting
	~~Rejected (no need to count)~~

	5:		5: Accepted no need counting
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	~~Accepted no need counting~~

	6: voting separately on each subpoint		6: voting separately on each subpoint

	6.1:		6.1: Accepted no need to count
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	=> means we remove suppleant from lists		=> means we remove suppleant from lists
	~~Accepted no need to count~~

	6.2		6.2: accepted
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	~~accepted~~

	6.3		6.3: Accepted
	Y:		Y:
	N		N
	Remark: take care of side effects		Remark: take care of side effects
	yet it doesn't mean the seat can go to another party		yet it doesn't mean the seat can go to another party
	~~Accepted~~

	6.4		6.4: Accepted
	Y: 17+ 10		Y: 17+ 10
	N 7 +4		N 7 +4
	~~Accepted~~

	6.5		6.5: Accepted
	Y:		Y:
	N		N
	~~Accepted~~
	Comment: It means people can still go for an election while being elected in another assembly		Comment: It means people can still go for an election while being elected in another assembly

	7:		7: Rejected
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	Remark: reality is more complex, small companies also have public money.		Remark: reality is more complex, small companies also have public money.
	Excludes cooperation.		Excludes cooperation.
	~~Rejected~~

	8:		8: Rejected
	Y:11+3 =14		Y:11+3 =14
	N:8+9 = 17		N:8+9 = 17
	Remark: very valuable, but should this be in our program?		Remark: very valuable, but should this be in our program?
	~~Rejected~~

	9:		9: accepted (unanimity)
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	~~accepted (unanimity)~~
			10: Accepted
	10:
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	Remark: is already a fact		Remark: is already a fact
	Not true: Belgacom for instance provides both		Not true: Belgacom for instance provides both
	~~Accepted~~

	11:		11: Accepted
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	Remark: this is about how we want to introduce basic income and determine wether it's possible or not		Remark: this is about how we want to introduce basic income and determine wether it's possible or not
	~~Accepted~~

	=='''Statutes'''==		=='''Statutes'''==

Vincent.L at 11:18, 25 January 2014

2014-01-25T11:18:59Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 13:18, 25 January 2014
Line 1:		Line 1:
	~~Vote~~		=Results of EGA2014-01 Voting - day 1=

	'''~~Programme~~'''		=='''Program'''==

	1:		1:
Line 34:		Line 34:
	N:		N:
	Accepted no need counting		Accepted no need counting

			6: voting separately on each subpoint

	~~6: voting separately on each subpoint~~
	6.1:		6.1:
	Y:		Y:
Line 41:		Line 42:
	=> means we remove suppleant from lists		=> means we remove suppleant from lists
	Accepted no need to count		Accepted no need to count

	6.2		6.2
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:
	accepted		accepted

	6.3		6.3
	Y:		Y:
Line 51:		Line 54:
	yet it doesn't mean the seat can go to another party		yet it doesn't mean the seat can go to another party
	Accepted		Accepted

	6.4		6.4
	Y: 17+ 10		Y: 17+ 10
	N 7 +4		N 7 +4
	Accepted		Accepted

	6.5		6.5
	Y:		Y:
Line 68:		Line 72:
	Excludes cooperation.		Excludes cooperation.
	Rejected		Rejected

	8:		8:
	Y:11+3 =14		Y:11+3 =14
Line 92:		Line 96:
	Remark: this is about how we want to introduce basic income and determine wether it's possible or not		Remark: this is about how we want to introduce basic income and determine wether it's possible or not
	Accepted		Accepted

	Statutes		=='''Statutes'''==
	Suggestion: Let's try to discuss more and answer to objections instead of voting directly
			Suggestion: Let's try to discuss more and answer to objections instead of voting directly

	12A:		12A:
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:

	12B:		12B:
	Y:		Y:
	N:		N:

	12C:		12C:
	Y:		Y:

Vincent.L: Vincent.L moved page Events/EGA:2014-01/voting/day1 to Events/EGA:2014-01/voting-day1 without leaving a redirect

2014-01-25T11:10:22Z

Vincent.L moved page Events/EGA:2014-01/voting/day1 to Events/EGA:2014-01/voting-day1 without leaving a redirect

← Older revision

Revision as of 13:10, 25 January 2014

Vincent.L: Created page with "Vote '''Programme''' 1: Y: 14 + 3 =17 N: 9 +9= 18 postponed Remark: -Think about implication towards who owns this debt (to debate in arglab?) -This is..."

2014-01-25T11:05:21Z

Created page with "Vote '''Programme''' 1: Y: 14 + 3 =17 N: 9 +9= 18 postponed Remark: -Think about implication towards who owns this debt (to debate in arglab?) -This is..."

New page

Vote

'''Programme'''

1:
Y: 14 + 3 =17
N: 9 +9= 18
postponed
Remark:
-Think about implication towards who owns this debt (to debate in arglab?)
-This is the same as bankrupt ?

2:
Y: 16 + 8= 24
N:10 + 4= 14
accepted

3:
Y:11+ 10=21
N:12+3 = 15
Remark: "The most important" could be excessive
Accepted

4:
Y:
N:
Remark: there is more to do about animal rights than banning hunt
Question: is it also about fishing?
No, just hunting
Rejected (no need to count)

5:
Y:
N:
Accepted no need counting

6: voting separately on each subpoint
6.1:
Y:
N:
=> means we remove suppleant from lists
Accepted no need to count
6.2
Y:
N:
accepted
6.3
Y:
N
Remark: take care of side effects
yet it doesn't mean the seat can go to another party
Accepted

6.4
Y: 17+ 10
N 7 +4
Accepted
6.5
Y:
N
Accepted
Comment: It means people can still go for an election while being elected in another assembly

7:
Y:
N:
Remark: reality is more complex, small companies also have public money.
Excludes cooperation.
Rejected

8:
Y:11+3 =14
N:8+9 = 17
Remark: very valuable, but should this be in our program?
Rejected

9:
Y:
N:
accepted (unanimity)

10:
Y:
N:
Remark: is already a fact
Not true: Belgacom for instance provides both
Accepted

11:
Y:
N:
Remark: this is about how we want to introduce basic income and determine wether it's possible or not
Accepted

Statutes
Suggestion: Let's try to discuss more and answer to objections instead of voting directly
12A:
Y:
N:
12B:
Y:
N:
12C:
Y:
N:
Whole block Rejected, because no consensus (no vote)

13:
Y:
N:
Remark: risk that a new specific rule will be made each time someone is to be kicked out?
Rejected

14:
Y:16+6=22
N:6+5=11
Accepted